Why are Maggots Considered "Yuckier" than Leeches?: Examining our Associations with Maggots and Leeches in Wound Care and Beyond

DMCA.com Protection Status
Blog Category: 

By Ron Sherman MD, MSC, DTM&H

Two hundred years ago, Joseph Joubert wrote: “To teach is to learn twice.” For me, preparing for a lecture or workshop is like learning the latest information all over again. But giving the lecture and pondering over the students’ questions is like learning a third time. This is one of the reasons that I so enjoy teaching.

I recently presented the maggot therapy hands-on workshop at the Wild on Wounds (WOW) conference in Las Vegas (The BTER Foundation has produced the maggot therapy workshop for WOW for the past five years). For the first time, I was asked the question: Why are health care professionals more accepting of leech therapy than maggot therapy?

I had actually pondered this question several times over the past few years, but never gave it as much thought as I felt it deserved at that moment. Now I believe that our revelations are worthy even of this valuable blog space.

In my mind, three characteristics of maggots set them apart from leeches (or, at least give them a higher score on the “yuck-o-meter”): their place in medical history, our personal contact with them, and the cultural and scientific context in which we place them (the associations or mental connections).

The first difference between maggot therapy and leech therapy is the long and continuous employment of leeches – but not maggots – in medical practice. While we may joke that maggot therapy has developed over millions of years of evolution, the fact is that the intentional application of fly larvae to treat wounds is, at least in Western medicine, a practice less than 100 years old. On the other hand, leeching (hirudotherapy) has been practiced for thousands of years, and is well-documented in the ancient European, Eastern, and Middle-Eastern medical texts.

Additionally, very few people have actually seen a leech, except, perhaps, from images in books or film. But many, if not most people, have seen – and smelled – maggots in their garbage, or in dog poop, or on a patients’ wound . . . or somewhere else, equally disgusting and unexpected. The odor of these rotting things is enough, alone, to turn our stomachs; and that odor stains our mental image of the maggots more indelibly than it stains nasal neurons.

These two factors contribute to the mental connections that we form around maggots and leeches. On top of these intellectual and emotional associations, we must add the natural and cultural contexts in which we associate maggots with flies and filth, garbage and death . . . the very antithesis of everything society proclaims is healthy. Leeches may be “blood suckers”, but they elicit none of these repulsive sentiments. For many people, the first thought that comes to mind after hearing the word “leeches” is traditional medicine itself.

Altogether, these are the emotional associations which I believe help explain why we sometimes see more resistance to employing maggots in our hospitals and clinics, than there is towards employing leeches.

What do you think, and what has been your experience?

Joseph Joubert: The Notebooks of Joseph Joubert. Edited and Translated by Paul Auster. North Point Press, San Franscisco, 1983.
Robert and Michele Root-Bernstein: Honey Mud Maggots and Other Medical Marvels. Houghton Mifflin Company, New York, 1998.

About The Author
Ron Sherman MD, MSC, DTM&H has led a long career at the forefront of biotherapy, pioneering the development of medicinal maggots for over 25 years. He is now retired from his faculty position at the University of California, but continues to volunteer as Director and Board Chair of the BTER Foundation, and as Laboratory Director of Monarch Labs.

The views and opinions expressed in this blog are solely those of the author, and do not represent the views of WoundSource, Kestrel Health Information, Inc., its affiliates, or subsidiary companies.

Like what you've read? Click here to subscribe to the WoundSource ENEWS!

Recommended for You

  • September 1st, 2021

    By Steven A. Kahn, MD

    When treating severe burns, surgeons generally consider eschar removal to be the major factor and the top challenge in both initiating and planning for the optimal course of treatment for each patient. Before grafting, all devitalized tissue must be removed...

  • June 30th, 2021

    Wound bed preparation has been performed for decades in managing wounds of various etiologies. The wound healing process consists of a complex interlinked and independent cascade, which not all wounds follow in a consistent, organized manner. The TIMERS acronym, consisting of four general steps...

  • April 30th, 2021

    Complex and hard-to-heal chronic wounds impact millions of people globally. In the United States, care for these types of wounds exceeds $25 billion annually. Wound healing naturally progresses through the overlapping phases of hemostasis, inflammation, proliferation, and remodeling. With...

Important Notice: The contents of the website such as text, graphics, images, and other materials contained on the website ("Content") are for informational purposes only. The Content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. The content is not intended to substitute manufacturer instructions. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or product usage. Refer to the Legal Notice for express terms of use.